Jump to content
Sclero Forums
ladyhawke

Do you keep asking "how did I get this?"

Recommended Posts

Hi All,

 

First off, let me tell you this story. I worked 18 years in a tire plant as a tire builder. Never had any time off no matter where I worked. I've done bungee jumping, sky diving, very active person. Busy all the time. I used to say, "I don't have time to be sick" . Oh the arrogance of the healthy. Well, I do now. Anyway, the company that I worked for had an outside agency to handle their short term disability (STD) and long term disability (LTD) people. I was going through so much and this woman on the phone was so good to me. She's also a nurse, so knows a lot. She handled my STD claim. First I had polymyositis, then scleroderma. When I told her about the scleroderma she said that she handled a lot of compensation claims from Gold miners who got it from breathing in the silica dust. Well, I have 4 cats here. actually 5 right now as I'm cat sitting for a month. I have one of those automatic cat litter boxes and I use a good name brand clumping cat litter. I wrote to the company and asked for the ingredients as it's not stated on the container. I specifically asked about silica. I got a very nice response. Here's the part I want you to know:

 

All our clay based cat litter products are completely safe, non-toxic, and non-hazardous Our clays are naturally occurring clay minerals known as “fuller’s earth.†Our clay based litters may also contain small amounts of crystalline silica in the form of quartz. Crystalline silica, in the form of quartz, is the second most abundant mineral in the earth’s crust. (This mineral is even found in beach sand.) Extensive research and testing has proven that consumer exposure to respirable crystalline silica during normal use of clay-based cat litter poses no risks to humans or their pets. Pets and their owners have used clay-based litters safely for over 65 years. During that time there has been no scientific evidence linking clay-based litters with any adverse health effects on cats or their owners.

 

Okay. So I do a search on "respirable crystalline silica and scleroderma". It is definitely linked as far as an "occupational hazard". I did find one article that did mention cat litter and scleroderma but it was someone's blog.

 

Anyway, would like to see if anyone has any thoughts on this? How many of you have cats, and just any and all thoughts in general. I just wonder if this is what brought this on for me.

 

Hugs to all,

 

Lisa


Life is NOT meant to be a struggle. Life is meant to be joyously abundant.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Hi Lisa,

 

I have had anywhere from 1-5 cats at a time living in our homes. I am the only one who has ever handled the litter boxes and they have always been kept in the basement. I don't have Sclero but Gareth has undifferentiated connective tissue disease (UCTD).

 

Take care, Everyone.

 

Margaret

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Thanks for the responses here. Shelley -- well, from what I'm reading about silica exposure, it is in the dust that is inhaled that causes the problems. They do have silica in the tread of the tire. And I did think of that, but by the time I would handle it, there would be no dust present. It would already be in the tread which I would put on the tire. No one else at my plant has it, and as far as I know, no one at any other plants either. But I could see it causing problems in the cat litter because it's so dusty and goes right into the air. I wonder if some people are more susceptible than others? But after I posted this, I did a search on soapstone and silica. My hubby for a short period of time did some soapstone carving. And sure enough, there's silica in most soapstone. I wonder what else it's in? I just wonder where this came from as I'm sure everyone else here does too. I'm sure none of us, would have imagined we'd be here and yet here we are. I also want to say how grateful that I am to have found this Sclero group. I may not post much, but I do come and read lots and anytime I've posted, you are all here. I hope you know what a lifeline you all are, those who have been here awhile and those who are new. If we have to have this disease, I'm glad to be here with you - Lisa


Life is NOT meant to be a struggle. Life is meant to be joyously abundant.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

A side note here, I found this:

 

There is potential for danger ONLY when crystalline silica particles are in the air. There may be materials that contain silica but if the operations on those materials do not generate dust, there is little chance of inhaling the silica. Likewise, there may be silica particles in the air even though you don't see any dust.


Life is NOT meant to be a struggle. Life is meant to be joyously abundant.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Hi Lisa,

 

We have had 3 cats' for the last 20 years, our last remaining cat died last year at the ripe old age of 18 years. Regarding the kitty litter, I was the main person who used to change the kitty litter. Back in the days when we were watching our money, we used to buy the cheap old kitty litter which looked like gravel. The dust was terrible pouring it in the kitty tray, and I am sure I inhaled some of that dust. It was only a few years before my diagnosis of Scleroderma, I changed the kitty litter to the biodegradable litter(the one that looks like bunched up cardboard).

 

I have often wondered myself, what I could have been exposed to, we have renovated many houses. One house in particular, we had the old asbestos roof removed, I also sanded back walls that used to have the old lead paint in it. When you are in your 20's, you don't think about using masks, etc., you think you are invincible. So who knows, what triggered my diagnosis.

 

I'll be interested to hear other peoples comments on this.

 

Regards

Summer

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Hi Lisa and Summer,

We have a good page on Causes of Scleroderma: Silica.

When I volunteered to donate blood samples to the Scleroderma Family and DNA Registry, I asked the Coordinator who spoke to me if they were getting any closer to discovering the causes of scleroderma. She said that among other things, they were investigating the possibility that it required several genes to be present (and you needed to have all of them) plus an environmental trigger, which might vary from person to person.

I don't know how that line of investigation has panned out. From a completely personal view, with absolutely nothing to back me up, I would think it makes some sense and might account for the great variability in the course of the illness from person to person, as well as the rarity of scleroderma.

Given that exposure to airborn silica particles from things like cat litter isn't at all uncommon, I'd think if it were the sole cause of scleroderma there would be more cases of it or the majority of us would have had cats. Plus, think of all the kids who've played in sandboxes or spent all summer on the beach.

Regardless, I think those of us who do handle cat litter or work in dusty environments should be very careful, as a matter of course. When Cat5 (named for a kind of co-axial cable - the Handsome Hubby is an 'alpha-geek wink.gif ) was still with us, I'd put her litter pan into a big plastic bag to empty it and then fill it under an old clear plastic shower curtain. No, I'm not that careful, I just really hate dusting! laugh.gif

Anyhow, those are my thoughts on the subject.


Jeannie McClelland

(Retired) ISN Director of Support Services

(Retired) ISN Sclero Forums Manager

(Retired) ISN Blog Manager

(Retired) ISN Assistant News Guide

(Retired) ISN Artist

International Scleroderma Network

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

<< I just wonder where this came from as I'm sure everyone else here does too.>>

 

Hi Lisa ,

 

If anyone should have something *funky* in my house, it should be me and not Gareth. I am the one who has been doing stained glass work for years, taking care of flower gardens, stripping and painting funiture, etc. It's only been the past few years where industries/products tells you to wear masks when working in dust, painting, etc. I also helped my Dad strip the old asbestos side tiles off the farm house 35 + yrs ago --- long before they knew asbestos caused mesotheliomas. It's a very interesting question. Maybe it's MY genes that are so messed up, passed on to Gareth and made him predisposed for *funky* stuff!!!

 

Take care, Everyone.

Margaret

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I see that you too have Polymyositis. I was just diagnosed with that last June. Can you tell me what symptoms you have from that?

 

I suffer from such muscle pain and I can't tell if its from the sclero or the poly.

 

Thanks.

 

Peggy

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Hi Peggy,

 

We've got a great page on Polymyositis. I won't say it has everything you want to know, but it does have a vast amount of information. :)

 

I've not been diagnosed with that, but have a lot of muscle pain and upper torso/arm weakness. My rheumatologist and I weren't happy with prednisone, so what he's prescribed for me is a Cox-2 NSAID anti-inflammatory and a muscle relaxant taken three times a day. It doesn't help with the weakness, but reduces the pain on most days down to an amount I can usually ignore.

 

Best wishes and a warm smile in lieu of a painful hug,


Jeannie McClelland

(Retired) ISN Director of Support Services

(Retired) ISN Sclero Forums Manager

(Retired) ISN Blog Manager

(Retired) ISN Assistant News Guide

(Retired) ISN Artist

International Scleroderma Network

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Interesting thread. I've had cats for the years, the last one 17 years and the new one 8 months. I always do the litter duty and 99% of the time we use fullers earth type litter.

 

That said I think it must be a physical predisposition to sclero plus environmental/emotional factors and may well be a different combination of each for each person with sclero. That would at least explain why we are all so different!

 

Amanda


Amanda Thorpe

ISN Sclero Forums Senior Support Specialist

ISN Video Presentations Manager

ISN Blogger

(Retired) ISN Sclero Forums Assistant Manager

(Retired) ISN Email Support Specialist

International Scleroderma Network (ISN)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Wow, thanks everyone for all of your replies. This has been very interesting. After reading your replies and doing more research, I don't think the cat litter or the soapstone carving that my hubby did, "caused" this for me. But I wish I had been aware of the cat litter thing long before now. I've switched now to a cat litter that is clumping and flushable and made from corn. I think to actually get scleroderma from silica dust, you would have to be in it long term, like the gold miners are. (Just my opinion).

 

Jeannie: I'm glad you mentioned the muscle pain and upper torso/arm weakness. I have the very same. I've come off the prednisone and have watched myself go downhill. I was on it for 2 1/2 years. Finally, slowly weaned off of it. But man, I miss it!!! I feel everything and have lost what stamina I did have. This stinks! I'm going to ask my rheumatologist about what you are taking when I see him in May. I take ibuprofen but it doesn't help much at all.

 

Peggy....I would say the muscle pain is from the sclero. I don't know for sure, but I think if I just had the poly, I would be ok. I have no proof of this, it's just what is in my head.

 

Thanks again to everyone. I'm glad that I posted this one. It's eased my mind.

 

Hugs to all - Lisa


Life is NOT meant to be a struggle. Life is meant to be joyously abundant.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Hi Lisa,

 

Did I mention I also take Plaquenil? It's helped with the pain and the fatigue. It took a while to fully kick in, but my goodness, I finally don't miss the prednisone.

 

I weaned off prednisone very slowly (1 mg every 3-6 weeks) and didn't know if I was going to be able to stay off it. I had some really rough months, so bad that my rheumatologist suggested I start on the lowest dose and titrate up until I was at an acceptable pain level.

 

Corn based cat litter, huh? I wish I'd known about it when Cat5 was still around. Maybe once the border collie count is down a little, we'll think about another kitty. Right now the dogs have finally gotten over not having her to boss them around. It was hilarious watching 6lbs of itty bitty kitty ruling 100lbs (total) of border collie with an iron paw.

 

Big hugs,


Jeannie McClelland

(Retired) ISN Director of Support Services

(Retired) ISN Sclero Forums Manager

(Retired) ISN Blog Manager

(Retired) ISN Assistant News Guide

(Retired) ISN Artist

International Scleroderma Network

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

<<It was hilarious watching 6lbs of itty bitty kitty ruling 100lbs (total) of border collie with an iron paw.>>

 

Jeannie....we have one 15 lb cat that has no problem standing up his hind legs and smacking the 120 # Newf!!! Needless to say, the other 4 cats have free rein here, too!!!

 

Take care, Everyone.

Margaret

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Thanks Jeannie about the Plaquenil. I have a bunch of stuff written down to take to the rheumatologist in May and I've added that to it. Something has to give here. Thanks again everyone. I woke up this morning to a snowstorm, we got dumped on overnight. Man, I wish summer was here!

 

Lisa


Life is NOT meant to be a struggle. Life is meant to be joyously abundant.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

×